¹Enobong Mbang Akpambang, Ph.D,²Aderonke Abimbola Ojo, Ph.D

¹Department of Public Law, Faculty of Law, Ekiti State University, Ado-Ekiti, Nigeria.

²Department of Private and Property Law, Faculty of Law, Ekiti State University, Ado-Ekiti, Nigeria.

DOI : https://doi.org/10.47191/ijsshr/v6-i4-39

Google Scholar Download Pdf
ABSTRACT

Under a presidential system of government, executive powers are vested on the President at the federal level and the Governor at the state or sub-national level. Given the wide powers constitutionally conferred on the executive arm of government along with immunity from civil or criminal proceedings, the instrument of impeachment is incorporated into the Constitution to act as a check and balance against authoritarianism or misuse of official power. The foremost objective of this article is to comparatively scrutinise the modus operandi for impeachment of the President or Governor in Nigeria and the United States of America (USA); the USA impeachment mechanism would be limited to the federal impeachment process of the President and the Vice President. The article employed desk-based or doctrinal and comparative research methods by placing reliance on both primary and secondary sources of information. The sources of information were analysed and inferences obtained were presented descriptively. The article revealed inter alia, that though Nigeria and USA practice presidential system of government as well as operate a federal system, yet, there are some procedural parallels and dissimilarities in their respective impeachment procedures. A case in point is that in the USA, an impeached official cannot subsequently be granted pardon by the President whereas in Nigeria, there is no constitutional clause barring the President or the Governor from granting pardon to a convicted elected executive office holder. The authors therefore, recommended inter alia, that a constitutional amendment should be introduced to sections 175 and 212 of the 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (1999 CFRN) with the goal of outlawing the President or Governor from granting pardon to an impeached official, as obtainable in the USA.

KEYWORDS:

Impeachment, Nigeria, Presidential System of Government, United States of America

REFERENCES

1) Aihe, D. O., Selected Essays on Nigerian Constitutional Law (Benin City: Idodo Umeh Publishers, 1985).

2) Akinnsanya, Adeoye, “Impeachment of Governor Abdulkadir Balarabe Musa of Kaduna State,” in Adeoye A. Akinnsanya & Gordon Idang (eds.) Nigerian Government and Politics, 1979-1983 (Calabar: Wusen Publishers, 2002).

3) Akpambang, Enobong Mbang, “Immunities and Tenure of Office in the Three Arms of Government in Nigeria: Legal Perspective,” (2016) 4(4) Global Journal of Politics and Legal Research, 43-59.

4) Anele, Kalu Kingsley, “A Comparative Analysis of the Impeachment Procedure in Nigeria and Indonesia: A Need for a Paradigm Shift,” (2022) 9(1) Lentera Hukum, 33-74.

5) Berger, Raoul, “Impeachment for “High Crimes and Misdemeanors,” (1970-1971) 44 Southern California Law Review, 395.

6) Berger, Raoul, Impeachment: The Constitutional Problems, First Edition (Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press, 1973).

7) Bessette, Joseph M. & Gary J. Schmitt, What Does “High Crimes and Misdemeanors” Mean? (American Enterprise Institute, November 2019).

8) Bestor, Arthur, “Impeachment,” (1973) 49(1) Washington Law Review, 255-285 (Reviewing Raoul Berger, “Impeachment: The Constitutional Problems” (1973)).

9) Blackstone, William, Commentaries on the Laws of England of Public Wrongs (Boston, MA: Beacon Press, 1962).

10) Bowman III, Frank O., “British Impeachment (1376-1787) and the Preservation of the America Constitutional Order,” (2019) 46(4) Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly, 745-792.

11) Brubaker, Stanley C., “Book Review: American Constitutional Law (2d Ed.) by Laurence M. Tribe,” (1989) 6(431) Constitutional Commentary, 469-494; retrieved from (accessed on 19 March 2023).

12) Chemerinsky, Erwin, Constitutional Law, Fourth Edition (New York: Wolters Kluwer, 2013).

13) Fagbadebo, Omololu & Suzanne Francis, “Impeachment as an Accountability Measure in a Presidential System? Views from Nigeria’s Fourth Republic,” (2014) 3(2) African Journal of Governance and Development, 16-34.

14) Fagbadebo, Omololu, “An Analysis of the Judicial Review of the Impeachment Procedure in Anambra, Oyo, and Plateau in Nigeria’s Fourth Republic,” (2020) XXVII(48) Transylvanian Review, 12211-12219.

15) Fagbadebo, Omololu, Impeachment in the Nigerian Presidential System: Challenges, Successes and the Way Forward (Palgrave Macmillan, 2020).

16) Farrand, Max (ed.), The Records of the Federal Convention of 1787, Revised Edition (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1966).

17) Feerick, John D., “Impeaching Federal Judges: A Study of the Constitutional Provisions,” (1970) 39(1) Fordham University Law Review, 1-58.

18) Fenton, Paul S., “The Scope of the Impeachment Power, (1970) 65(5) Northwestern University Law Review, 719-758.

19) Garner, Bryan A. (ed.), Black’s Law Dictionary, Eighth Edition (St. Paul, MN: West Thompson Publishers, 2004).

20) Gerhardt, Michael J., “The Lessons of Impeachment History,” (1999) 67 George Washington Law Review, 603-625.

21) Goldberg, Arthur J., “The Question of Impeachment,” (1974)1(1) Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly, 5-12.

22) Hamilton, Alexander, “The Powers of the Senate Continued” in Jacob E. Cooke (ed.) The Federalist Papers No. 65 (Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press, 1961).

23) Huq, Aziz, Tom Ginburg & David Landau, “The Comparative Constitutional Law of Presidential Impeachment,” (2021) 88 University of Chicago Law Review, 81- 164.

24) McLoughlin, Merrill, The Impeachment and Trial of President Clinton: The Official Transcripts, from the House Judiciary Committee Hearings to the Senate Trial, First Edition (New York: Times Books, 1999).

25) Morgan, Charles, et al., “Impeachment: An Historical Overview,” (1974) 5(3) Seton Hall Law Review, 689- 719.

26) Mowoe, Kehinde M., Constitutional Law in Nigeria (Lagos: Malthouse Press Limited, 2008).

27) Nagel, Robert F., “American Constitutional Law,” (1979) 127(4) University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 1174-1194 (Reviewing Laurence H. Tribe, American Constitutional Law; DOI: (accessed on 19 March 2023).

28) Nathanson, Nathaniel L., “Impeachment: The Constitutional Problems,” (1974) 2(1) Florida State University Law Review, 209-218 (Reviewing Raoul Berger, “Impeachment: The Constitutional Problems” (1973)).

29) Neumann, Richard K., “The Revival of Impeachment as a Partisan Political Weapon,” (2007) 34(2) Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly, 161-327.

30) Oduwobi, Tunde, “Deposed Rulers under the Colonial Regime in Nigeria,” (2003) 171(3) Cahiers d’Etudes africaines, 553- 571; DOI: (accessed on 19 March 2023).

31) Oladosu, Oluwasegun & Ajayi Adetokunbo Olaiya, “Kingship and Integrity in Yoruba Traditional Society,” (2021) 4(2) Nigerian Journal of Christian Studies, 168-188.

32) Rehnquist, William H., “The Impeachment Clause: A Wild Card in the Constitution,” (1991) 85 Northwestern University Law Review, 903-918.

33) Robinson, Mairi & George Davidson (eds.), Chambers 21st Century Dictionary, (New Delhi, India: Allied Chambers (India) Limited, Reprinted 2006).

34) Rotunda, Ronald D. & John E. Nowak (eds.), Joseph Story: Commentaries on the Constitution (Carolina Academic Press, 1987).

35) Rotunda, Ronald D., “An Essay on the Constitutional Parameters of Federal Impeachment,” (1987-1988) 76(3) Kentucky Law Journal, 707-732.

36) Shin, Gi-Wook & Rennie J. Moon, “South Korea after Impeachment,” (2017) 28(4) Journal of Democracy, 117-131; DOI: (accessed on 16 March 2023).

37) Tomoszek, Maxim, “Impeachment in the U.S. Constitution and Practice- Implications for the Czech Constitution,” (2017) 17(1) International and Comparative Law Review, 129-146; DOI: (accessed on 19 March 2023).

38) Tribe, Laurence H., American Constitutional Law, Second Edition (Mineola, New York: Foundation Press, 1988).

39) Udofa, Imo, “The Impeachment Power of the Legislature under the Nigerian and American Constitutions Compared,” (2015) 2(4) International Journal of Law and Legal Jurisprudence Studies, 1-22.

40) Udombana, Ngozi and Prudence Adula Okparavero, “Impeachment Power of the Legislature and Executive Unaccountability in Nigeria: Between Rhetoric and Practice,” (2020) 6(6) International Journal of Law, 252-263.

VOlUME 06 ISSUE 04 APRIL 2023